View or Change a Reservation

You'll need to provide the information below to find your reservation. Once found, you can then modify or cancel that reservation online.


* If you want to add another room with a different occupancy, first add this room to your cart, then come back and add the next room.


Additional Options



Have a Promo or Group Code? Enter it now.

You have entered the code: Edit | Remove



23 Grand Avenue, Shelter Island, NY 11965
1-631-7490018 more info show less

4 stars4.5

Overlooking a Peconic River harbor, this charming inn in 19th-century buildings is a 7-minute walk from the North Ferry terminal and a 13-minute walk from Crescent Beach. Country-chic, TV-free rooms feature hardwood floors, luxe bedding, mini fridges and rainfall showers. Upgraded rooms add water views and/or sitting areas. Suites offer claw-foot tubs; 1 has a terrace. Kids (up to 2) stay at no cost with an adult. Complimentary breakfast is served in-room, in a bright lobby, or on a vibrant porch offering harbor views. Morning and evening drinks are provided in the lobby. There's a cafe, and a restaurant with a patio and views of the water.


Popular Attractions

  • Venture Out Paddle Board Rentals
  • Antique Carousel
  • Sylvester Manor Educational Farm
  • Long Island Mac Arthur
  • Concierge Desk
  • Restaurant
  • Bar
  • Coffee Shop
  • Free Parking
  • Internet Access - Wireless
  • Complimentary Continental Breakfast

Sort by


Show All Show Less


Show All Show Less

Packages & Rates

Show All Show Less

Available Rooms

Show All Show Less

Alternate Properties

Continue Shopping Your Cart

Guests who reserved this room also bought these add-ons & extras.